A
study to evaluate the Video Assisted Teaching Module (VATM) on care of dementia
patients developed for B.Sc Nursing Students in a
selected college of nursing, Mangalore
Midhula Austin1, N. Balasubramanian2
1Nursing Student,
Shree Devi College of Nursing, Maina Tower, Ballalbagh, Mangalore-575003
2HOD, Psychiatric
Nursing, Shree Devi College of Nursing Maina Tower, Ballalbagh, Mangalore-575003
E-mail: snbalu78@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Background: Dementia is the progressive,
degenerative brain disease with maladaptive, cognitive response that has
features of a loss of intellectual abilities and interferes with the patient’s
usual social or occupational activities. The loss of intellectual ability
includes an impairment of memory, judgment, and abstract thought. It is not
curable and reversible. They need adequate care and support. The nurses have a
vital role in taking care of dementia patients. Caring requires a considerable
amount of understanding which makes a therapeutic way of dealing with patient1.
AIM: The aim of the study is to develop a video assisted
teaching module on care of dementia patients for B.Sc
Nursing students.
METHOD: A pre-experimental research design of one group pre
and post-test with an evaluative approach was used for the present study.
Purposive sampling technique was used to select the samples. The researcher
developed a Video Assisted Teaching Module on care of Dementia patients and
data was collected through the structured closed ended questionnaire on care of
dementia patient among B.Sc nursing students
RESULT: Descriptive and inferential statistics was used to analyse the data. Pre-test assessment revealed that most
(96%) of third year B.Sc nursing students had average
knowledge and only 4% had poor knowledge. The post-test revealed that 72% had
gained good knowledge, 28% of them gained very good knowledge. The total mean
percentage of pre-test knowledge score was 40.68% (13.2±1.97) and the mean
post-test knowledge score was 73.25% (23.44±2.64) showing an effectiveness of
32.57% (10.42±2.25). Significance of difference between pre-test and post-test
was statistically tested using paired ‘t’ test and it was found very highly significant
(t=32.75, p<0.05). There was no association between pre-test knowledge score
and post-test knowledge score with demographic variables.
INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSION: The findings of
the study reveal that there was highly significant increase in the knowledge of
third year B.Sc nursing students regarding care of
dementia patients. Hence, it is concluded that VATM is highly effective in
improving the knowledge of the third year B.Sc
nursing students.
INTRODUCTION:
Dementia produces decline in intellectual
functioning, and onset is gradual2.Dementia is common disorders
among elderly and thought to be the fourth leading cause of death among adults
in many nations following heart disease, cancer and stroke3.
Current estimates reveal that there are
about 65.7 million cases of dementia in the world by 2030, there will be about
35 million people suffering from dementia. The overall prevalence of dementia
ranges from 5 percent to 7 percent. Alzheimer’s disease is the most common
dementia disorder accounting for 80 percent of all cases of dementia4.Dementia
results in decline of reasoning, memory, and other mental abilities (the
cognitive functions). This decline eventually impairs the ability to carry out
everyday activities such as driving; household chores; and even personal care
such as bathing, dressing, and feeding or often called activities of daily
living2. Dementia affects all age groups in the society and is not
linked with social class, gender, ethnic group or geographical location and
although dementia is more common among elderly persons, younger person also can
affect7.
NEED FOR THE STUDY:
According to the 2011 world population
prospects by the United Nations department of economic and social affairs by
2050, the number of Indians aged above 80 will increase more than 6 times from
the current number of 78 lakhs to nearly 5.14 crores .
Dementia is becoming more prevalent among the elderly. The prevalence of
dementia projected to quadruple by the year 2047.Dementing illness are the most
common disorders among elderly and thought to be the fourth leading cause of
death among adults in many nations Very little is known about the prevalence of
dementia and how to care the dementia patients5.
Dementia is the disease of the 21st
century. Therefore becoming knowledgeable about the care of dementia patients,
this is one of the important long-term strategies for nursing personnel. Caring
for a person with dementia can have high physical and emotional costs.Since many of the studies and researcher’s own
experience reveal that an inadequate knowledge among nursing students regarding
care of dementia patients, the researcher wants to improve their knowledge by
using a video assisted teaching module6.
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY:
q To assess the
knowledge of third year nursing students regarding the care of dementia
patients prior to the implementation of
VATM and after implementation of VATM
q To find out the
significant difference between the pre and post
test knowledge scores of third year B.SC nursing students regarding care of dementia patients.
q To find out the
association between Pre and post knowledge scores of third year B.SC nursing
students regarding care of dementia patients with their selected demographic
variables.
ASSUMPTION:
¨ B.Sc nursing students have some knowledge regarding care of dementia patient.
¨ The VATM would
enhance B.SC nursing students Knowledge on care of dementia patients.
¨ Knowledge may
vary from individual to individual and B.Sc nursing
students to B.Sc nursing students.
HYPOTHESIS
¨ H1:
There will be significant difference between the pre and post test knowledge
score of VATM regarding care of dementia patients.
¨ H2:
There will be significant association between pre and post test knowledge
scores regarding care of dementia patients and their selected demographic
variables at 0.05 level of significance.
DELIMITATIONS:
The study would be delimited to third
year B.Sc nursing students in selected nursing
colleges.
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY:
An evaluative approach and pre experimental design of one group pre-test
and post-test was selected to carry out the present study. The sample consist
of 50 Third year B.Sc Nursing Students who met the
inclusion criteria were selected through purposive
sampling technique. .The Video Assisted Teaching Module on care of dementia patient was developed and a
structured closed ended knowledge questionnaire on care of dementia patient was
used for the data collection. Reliability of
the instrument was calculated by using Karl Pearson Correlation Coefficient
formula and significance of correlation was tested using Spearman Brown prophesy formula. The ‘r’ value was 0.82 and the tool was
found reliable. Pilot study was
conducted in Unity College of nursing, Mangalore and it was found
feasible and practicable. The main study was conducted in Shree Devi College Of
Nursing at Mangalore. Data was collected from 21.9.11 to 30.9.11. Pre-test was conducted among III
rd year B.Sc nursing students by using closed ended
questionnaire to assess the level of knowledge regarding care of dementia
patients. On 21-09-2011, the investigator collected the data from 9 am to 11 am.The investigator
personally explained the need and importance of study to the students before
data collection. The closed-ended questionnaire care of dementia patients was
distributed to the students and 30 minutes was given to fill the answers in the
presence of the investigator. Soon after pre-test the VATM was shown to the
samples. Evaluation of post-test was conducted after 7
days of the pre-test. On 28.9.11 and 30.9.11 the post-test was conducted by
using the same questionnaire and by the same method as pre-test.
RESULTS:
In the present study highest percentage 48% were in the age group of 20 years and
only 2% were from 22year and above. However, 38% were in the age group of
19years and 12 % were in the age group 21 years. It seems that most of them
were in the age group between19 -21 years. Gender wise distribution of III B.Sc nursing students shows that majority 90% of them was
females when compared to males (10%). It might be done to the nature of
profession. Percentage wise distribution of III year B Sc Nursing students
according to their religion reveals that both Hindus and Christian at 46%.
However, 8% were Muslims. The percentage distribution of third year B.Sc nursing students based on the type of family had
revealed that majority of students 56% from nuclear family, 32% of students
from joint family and 12% from extended family. However, this finding is in
contrast with the statement given by Park. K which states that joint family
system is common in India. Percentage wise distribution of the III year B.sc
nursing students according to their residence shows highest percentage 52% were
from semi urban areas and 14% were from urban areas. However, 34% were from
rural areas. The percentage distribution of third year B.Sc
nursing students on source of information had revealed that majority of
respondents72% has no information, 16% of respondents obtained information from
mass media and 12% of respondents obtained information from friends.
Percentage wise distribution of the III
year B.sc nursing students according to their pre test knowledge shows highest
percentage 96% have average knowledge and 4% have good knowledge and their post
test knowledge shows highest percentage 72% have good knowledge and 28% have
very good knowledge..
The hypothesis was tested using paired‘t’ test. The value of‘t’
was calculated to analyze the difference in knowledge of the third year B.Sc nursing students regarding care of dementia patients.
Significance of difference between pre-test
and post-test knowledge scores
N=50
|
Areas |
Mean |
SD |
SE |
‘t’ value |
|
Meaning and
causes |
11.11 |
1.69 |
0.24 |
46.02* |
|
Signs and
symptoms and diagnostic evaluations |
13 |
2.65 |
0.37 |
34.69* |
|
Care of dementia
patients |
9.2 |
2.14 |
0.30 |
30.40* |
|
Total |
10.42 |
2.25 |
0.32 |
32.75* |
Table value =2.009
at 0.05 level *
Highly significant, p<0.05
Paired ‘t’ test
was calculated to assess the pre- and post-test knowledge scores of third year B.Sc nursing students regarding care of dementia patients
showed a highly significant difference in all the areas. Hence, it can be
interpreted that the difference in mean score values related to all the above
mentioned areas were true difference and not by chance. So, the null hypothesis
is rejected. It shows that the VATM was effective for all the areas.
Chi square was calculated to analyze the association between pre-
test and post- test knowledge scores with demographic variables. The study had shown that, there is no
association between pre- test and post- test knowledge scores with demographic
variables.
The findings of the present study showed
a highly significant difference (t=2.009, PO.05) between mean pre-test (40.68)
and post-test (73.25) knowledge scores. The scores of the sample after the
administration of the VATM were considerably high. This suggests that the
improvement in knowledge scores was due to the effect of the VATM.
DISCUSSION:
Overall comparison of mean, SD and mean% of pre- and post-test knowledge
scores on care of dementia patients
revealed that the overall mean percentage of pre-test was 40.68% whereas, in
post-test the mean percentage was 73.25% thus, depicting 32.6% overall
difference in mean percentage.
Paired ‘t’ test was used to analyse the difference in the knowledge score of the
third year B.Sc nursing students regarding care of dementia patients. A
significant increase in the post-test score was observed in the knowledge of
third year B.Sc nursing students regarding care of
dementia patients. Hence the researcher hypothesis “the mean post-test
knowledge of the third year B.Sc nursing students will be
significantly higher than the mean pre-test knowledge scores” was accepted
(t=2.009,p<0.05). It revealed that VATM was very effective in improving the
knowledge level of the third year B.Sc nursing
students regarding care of dementia patients.
]In order to
determine the significant association of pre- and post-test knowledge score
with selected variables, chi-square test was used. In pre-test the calculated
chi square values of demographic variables like age, sex, religion monthly
income, type of family, residence and source of information about dementia
(3.42, 1.51, 1.12, 0.26, 0.68, 0.50,2.36) not significant at 0.05 level of
significant. In the post-test the chi square values of demographic variables
like age, sex, religion monthly income, type of family, residence and source of
information about dementia were (4.30, 0.77, 1.12, 1.69, 0.073,1.19,3.87) not
significant at 0.05 level.
CONCLUSION:
From the findings of the present study it can be concluded that the
video-assisted teaching module regarding care of dementia patients was
effective to improve the knowledge of third year B.Sc
nursing students.
Prior to the implementation of VATM the mean percentage score of the
third year B.Sc nursing students was 40.68% which
signified poor knowledge. However, after implementation of VATM the mean
percentage was 73.25% revealing good knowledge and the effectiveness was 32.6%.
IMPLICATIONS:
The findings of the present study have implications in the field of
nursing education, nursing practice, nursing administration and nursing
research.
Nursing practice:
¨ Health education is an important tool for health
care agency. It is one of the most cost effective interventions to promote
healthy living.
¨ Nurses working in the hospital as well as in the
community should be equipped with knowledge on dementia and alternative
modalities for reduction of these difficulties of dementia.
¨ Nurses are the key providers of preventive, curative
and rehabilitative services to individual and communities.
¨ Nurses in their educative role are in a better
position to mould the health related behaviour.
¨ Nurses are acting as the health promoters. They play
important role in educating care givers regarding alternative therapies for
reduction of difficulties of dementia and help them to lead a healthy life.
Health education can be imparted in the wards, OPDs, primary health centre and
schools through various methods like structured exercise programmes, lectures, pamphlets, SIM, VATM and PTP.
Nursing education:
¨ The health care delivery system at present is giving
more emphasis on preventive rather than curative aspect. It is the
responsibility of the individual to take care of one’s own health.
¨ The present study also gives priority for continuing
education programme as it upholds and maintains the knowledge and thus making
them more competent.
¨ The VATM can be used as an informational and
educational mode by the teachers and nursing personnel for educating the
public.
¨ Nursing students should be trained to acquire
knowledge in assessing old age people with dementia and to plan out teaching
programmes based on the same in the hospital and in the community setting.
¨ The holistic health care approach should be
emphasized during the training of nursing students.
¨ The nursing personnel should be given in service
education to update their knowledge and should also be trained to prepare and
conduct educational programmes like seminar, workshop, and conference regarding
this topic.
Nursing research:
¨ Nursing research represents a critically important
tool for the nursing profession to acquire knowledge.
¨ The emphasis on research and clinical studies are
needed to improve the quality of nursing care.
¨ The present study is only on the investigation in
the area of teaching the care of dementia patients.
¨ Dementia is more common among old age people and
many are unaware about the management of dementia patients. There is a great
need for research in the area of care of dementia.
¨ Nurse researchers should create favourable attitude
among old age people towards the management of dementia patients. This will
help them to lead healthy life by reducing the difficulties of dementia.
¨ This study has highlighted the effectiveness of VATM
on care of dementia patients. The findings can be utilized for conducting
research on the effectiveness of VATM on various aspects of nursing.
¨ The limitations
of the study are as follows
¨ The study was limited to the third year B.Sc nursing students in selected nursing colleges
Mangalore.
¨ Sample size was small so the generalization of the
findings is limited. Recommendations
Based on findings following recommendations were put forward for the further
research:
¨ A similar study can be undertaken on a larger sample
so that the results can be generalised.
¨ A similar study can be undertaken using other
teaching strategies.
¨ Nursing
administers need to be open to novel ideas for patient benefits
¨ The study can be replicated among the GNM students, B.Sc nursing students, Post B.Sc
nursing students and also can be replicate for care givers also.
¨ A comparative study can be conducted to assess the
knowledge of nursing students and staff nurses.
¨ A study can be conducted to assess the knowledge of
care givers regarding care of dementia patients.
¨ A follow-up study may be conducted to evaluate the
effectiveness of VATM on care of dementia patients.
¨ A similar study can be undertaken on nurses to
assess the skill in handling dementia patients.
¨ An experimental
study with control group could be conducted to establish the effect of video
assisted teaching module on care of dementia patients.
¨ A descriptive
study could be conducted to determine the knowledge and attitude of nurses when
caring dementia patients.
SUMMARY:
Percentage wise distribution of the III
year B.sc nursing students according to their pre test knowledge shows highest
percentage 96% have average knowledge and 4% have good knowledge Percentage
wise distribution of the III year B.sc nursing students according to their post
test knowledge shows highest percentage 72% have good knowledge and 28% have
very good knowledge. Overall and area-wise comparison of mean, SD and mean% of
pre- and post-test knowledge scores of the
revealed that the overall mean percentage of pre-test was 40.68%
whereas, in post-test the mean percentage was 73.25% thus, depicting 32.6%
overall difference in mean percentage.
Paired‘t’ test was used to calculate the
significant difference between pre- and post-test knowledge scores of third
year B.Sc nursing students regarding care of dementia
patients. It showed a highly significant difference in all the areas. Hence, it
can be interpreted that the difference in mean score values related to all the
above mentioned areas were true difference and not by chance. It shows that the
VATM was effective for all the areas
Chi square was calculated to analyze the
association between pre- test and post- test knowledge scores with demographic
variables. The study had shown that, there is no association between pre- test
and post- test knowledge scores with demographic variables.
BIBLIOGRAPHY:
1.
Kaplan
and Sadock. Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry. 5th
ed. USA: Lippincott Williams; 2000. P.3045.
2.
Stuart
GW, Laraia MT. Principles and practice of psychiatric
nursing. 8th ed. New Delhi: Mosby; 2005.
3.
Dr. Lalitha. K. Nursing Care
of the elderly with Neuro Psychiatric Problems.
National Conference
on Geriatric Nursing; Sept. 2005. Pondicherry. P.17-22.
4.
Dementia
statistics worldwide. URL: http://www.google.com [cited on 2007 Oct 6].
5.
Suddarth
and Brunner. Text book of Medical Surgical Nursing.9th ed. Noida; Lippincott: 2001. P.159.
6.
Kountya S. A simple blood test to predict
Alzheimer’s risk. The Times of India. 2007 October 16.P.17.
7.
Townsend
MC. Psychiatric mental health nursing. 5th ed.
New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers; 2007.
8.
Andrew Pollack: Advances in diagnosing Alzheimer’s Disease. The Hindu. 2007 Oct 17. P.18.
9.
Life expecting in India URL:http:www.google.com [cited
on 2007. Sep. 20].
10. Sreevani R. Mental health and psychiatric nursing.
2nded. Newdelhi: Jaypee
brothers medical publishers; 2007.
11. Keplan and sadock. Synopsis
of psychiatry. 10thed. Newdelhi: Kluwer pvt ltd; 2007.
12.
Wikimedia
foundation. Dementia. [cited 2010 Dec 1]. Available
from www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/dementia.com
Received on 25.06.2012 Modified on
13.08.2012
Accepted on 20.08.2012 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research 2(3): July-Sept.
2012; Page 113-117